Weberian Explanations Fo Social Class

In: Social Issues

Submitted By toriwatson97
Words 2293
Pages 10
Assess Weberian explanations for social class inequalities – 40 marks
In terms of social class, the lower classes face more discrimination and inequalities within every institution. Although Weber acknowledges that social class inequalities occur, but he also found that age, gender and ethnicity can be forms of discrimination as well. Not all of the working class can be homogenised for having the same experiences facing inequalities. The more power you have the less inequalities you have, this is why the working classes face more than the upper classes. Marxists would disagree with Weber as he under played the role of social class, Marx argued it was the source of inequality, they don’t place any focus on the other factors Weber identifies. Functionalists disagree with both Marx and Weber as Durkheim believed that ‘inequalities’ are just differences. They also say that those differences can be overcome because it’s down to the individuals themselves. They don’t believe that society creates the inequalities for people but that individuals create them for themselves.
Weber was influenced by Karl Marx and became the third founding father of sociology, he is known has the ghost of Marx due to the high similarity between the theories. Weber’s theory is a mix of structuralism and interactionism, showing elements of both Marxism and Functionalism within it. Weber believed that society as well as the individual can influence behaviour, but also that behaviour can influence the institutions. He also saw class and status as being two different concepts, unlike Marx, meaning that you could have status without having class and class without having status. Status is the relative social or professional position; standing. Class is known as the system of ordering society whereby people are divided into sets based on perceived social or economic status. Weber argued life chances…...

Similar Documents

Outline and Assess Marxists Explanations of Class Inequality

...Outline and assess Marxists explanations of class inequality There are many concerns in sociology as to whether class is still important. Many argue that it is not important as an individual’s identity is based on status, values and intelligence. Postmodernists claim that class is now dead. We can now be defined by consumption (what we spend money on) rather than class. However, others argue that class in still an influence on people’s lives, affecting certain aspects such as health and education. Marxism is a conflict theory that believes class division within society still exists between the bourgeoisie and the proletariat through the unequal distribution of wealth, power and status. The relationship between the two classes is based upon exploitation and class conflict. The proleteriat produce more goods only to get paid a low wage in return which enables the bourgeoisie to gain large profits. They believe the middle class also exists, but it is fragmented and undergone through the process of polarisation, either rising to the bourgeoisie or falling into the proletariat. The higher classes will get smaller and richer while the working class will get larger and poorer, eventually leading to revolution. Marshall argues that the underclass does not exist, claiming that the underclass would work if appropriate work was available. They also point out that half of those who claim benefits are in full-time work. They believe the concept of underclass is an ideological......

Words: 1281 - Pages: 6

Describe and Evaluate Social Explanations for Aggression

...Describe and evaluate social explanations for aggression (16 + 8 marks) There are a number of different theories which offer explanations for aggression. These include social psychological explanations and biological explanations. Some of the social explanations are social learning theory and deindividuation. Social learning theory was developed by Albert Bandura and is based on the behaviourist approach that our aggressive behaviour is learnt. He proposed that it is similar to operant conditioning where learning takes place due to observation and imitation. H explains that modelling has an influential role on the manner of the aggression, as if role models are seen t be aggressive this encourages those who observe them to exert similar behaviour. He also explains that vicarious learning takes place which is indirect rewarding of behaviour. AN example of this would include a child observing another child hitting someone in order to get the toy they desired. A number of factors influence the aggression levels learnt and shown in individuals, one of which is self-efficacy. This refers to the ability to perform the aggressive act, thus we are only likely to be aggressive if it is likely that we will succeed! Other characteristics of models influence whether someone will imitate behaviour, as if they have high power and status or are similar to he individual then this is likely to increase imitation. Therefore violence in the media is an increasing problem in the world......

Words: 1331 - Pages: 6

Social Class

...Social class, which is usually determined by a combination of one’s income, education, and occupation, may be less visible than other types of difference. However, in many countries where individualism is valued, it is common to believe that all people are created equal and that the same opportunities are available to everyone who has the innate talent and is willing to put in the effort. However, this position ignores the challenge of overcoming the social, educational, and networking resources of class origins. For example, the U.S. General Accounting Office reported that suburban school districts spend up to 10 times more on their public school systems than urban districts (U.S. GAO, 1997). This exercise is designed to help you to understand how social class could affect a person’s life experience due to differences in access and resources. Although social class in childhood does not necessarily determine status across one’s life span, it may limit educational and career options. This may make it more difficult for a person to achieve his or her career and personal goals. Of course, individuals within a social class can have very different experiences, due to a variety of factors. DIRECTIONS Complete the following two columns by thinking about what is apt to be the more common experience of a child growing up in Justin’s or Clark’s situation. Considering that Justin represents a child born into the lower socioeconomic class and Clark represents one born into the......

Words: 376 - Pages: 2

Social Class

...with college-educated parents (i.e., continuing-generation students). Study after study demonstrates that the financial, academic, and psychological barriers that these students encounter can significantly undermine their performance. The summit shined the national policy spotlight on this persistent social class achievement gap. Our own and others’ research shows that these feelings of exclusion and difference that the First Lady described are key factors that fuel the gap. While all students tend to question whether they belong and have what it takes to succeed, these concerns are magnified for first-generation and low-income students because of the mismatch they experience as they enter this “whole new world” of higher education. More needs to be done on campuses to raise awareness about how college environments can be unfamiliar and unwelcoming places to students who do not hail from middle and upper class worlds. Efforts to do just that are cropping up — from Massachusetts Institute of Technology to Northwestern University to Stanford University — at colleges and universities across the nation. Our research provides compelling evidence that talking about social class equips first-generation and low-income students to succeed. In our recent study, published in Psychological Science, we invited first-generation and continuing-generation students at the beginning of the school year to attend a one-hour program designed to help them transition to college. Unbeknownst to...

Words: 1431 - Pages: 6

Social Class

...Synthesis English Writing 1010 April 19 2013 Social Class Can Hinder Success The relationship between social class and our personal lives has been an ongoing link since the beginning of time. Social class affects relationships in our personal lives, our sense of self-worth, and can even go on to affect our future success. Angela Locke, author of Born Poor and Smart, relates to social class problems and is an example of how coming from a low social class can affect many aspects of everyday life. “Something I struggle with to this day us that I never developed the sense of entitlement that distinguishes the rich from the poor”… “I have never been able to convince myself that I am “worthy” of success” (Locke, 451). There is a stigma that if one grows up poor; they are not worth going to an exclusive college to further their education. In order for our culture to get out of this stigma and allow children to surpass their income defined boundaries we must teach our children that self-worth is something that comes from their own attitude and is not defined by outside sources. Schooling affects both education and income since most of the better paying jobs require a college degree or other advanced study. Many people associate schooling with personal success, however, students have more than poverty holding them back; they must first have a stable family for support and then they must change the way they think about themselves to succeed and to persevere while earning a college......

Words: 1111 - Pages: 5

Social Class

...Social Organized Crime Perspective Larry Fulse CJA /384 May 26, 2014 Dorothy Massey Social Institution is defined as an organizational system which functions to satisfy basic social needs by providing an ordered framework linking the individuals to the larger culture. This paper will provide more information as to how social institutions apply to organized crime, also which empirical and speculative theories are most applicable when applied to organized crime and criminal behavior. Organized crime within our social institution would exist because a small amount of the people who living within our society would willingly choose not to agree to abide by rules, regulations, morals, and laws both written and unwritten. Organized crime exists because and could be applied to our social institution. When we consider theories that are most applicable to the idea of a social institution and how they may apply to organized crime or criminal behavior in generally it is important to consider at least two theories. The Rational Choice Theory and the Theory of Differential Association are two theories that attempt to allow us to gain insight as to how social institution can not only be responsible for creating organized crime but also allude to criminal behaviors and allow us to see how individuals can come to a decision to choose their live their life in this fashion. Rational theory believes organized crime groups can make rational decisions when pertaining......

Words: 707 - Pages: 3

Social Class

...of a nation is built”. The consistent underperformance in education of students from low socio-economic environments, therefore, is a matter of great concern. When young people enter and exit the school setting without being given opportunities to advance to a greater level of socio-economic status, our system has failed to deliver its promise of a programme “that supports 21st century learning in all Australian schools” (ACARA, 2009, p. 1). Educational design must respond to the impact of class in Australia. Curriculum, pedagogy and assessment may all be tailored to respond to and reduce the impact of low socio-economic status on academic achievement. The 1966 release of Coleman’s Equality of Educational Opportunity Study clearly showed that a child’s socio-economic background has a dramatic impact on academic achievement. Coleman (1966) found that the single most significant determinant in educational success was the child’s home life, be that influenced by upper or lower class origins. More recent research by Berends, Lara-Cinisomo, Lucas, Maggio, Pebley, and Vaiana (2004) also concluded that the critical factor in influencing educational achievement in students was not “race, ethnicity, or immigrant status” (p. 1) but rather, the impact that comes from socio-economic factors. The question can no longer be whether there is sufficient evidence to support this belief, but instead, how can this knowledge be synthesised to close the achievement gap between......

Words: 1701 - Pages: 7

Social Class

...9/22/14 Social Transformation Social Change  Hunter Gatherers  Symbiosis with “nature”  Horticultural: Domesticated plants  Pastoral: Domesticated animals  H+B= Agricultural Revolution  Specialized labor  Empire  E= Industrial Revolution • Mechanical labor • Surplus goods  Present:  Post • Information/Economy • Specialized Knowledge  Bio-Tech Society • Changing human biology/genome 9/24/14 Social Construction of Reality  Thomas Theorem- Definition of the situation  Perception are reality: People can occupy the same social space but perceive a different reality  Background Assumptions  Stereotypes: Cultural assumptions  Ethnomethodology  Emotional disrupting creativity Dramaturgy  Goffman- Life is a con game  Impression Management  One person’s attempt to control the perceptions of others  Front- Social acting  Backstage- Preparing Proxemics-Personal Space  Proxemic Bubble  4 Rings  Intimate Space  Personal Zone  Social Space  Public 9/26/14 Social Groups  Two or more people  Share like activities and common goals  Possesses the spirit of “WE”  In-Group (US):  Group to which you are a member  Out-Group (THEM):  People outside or opposed/in competition with your group Typology of Groups  Primary (Close Association)  Intimate  Long-lasting  Expressive- emotional connection  Secondary (Loose Association)  Super......

Words: 1106 - Pages: 5

Social Class

...Bisola Mary Bello SPEA –V 443: Social Class Assignment. August 11th 2014 3:21 AM. 1. Discuss and explain PEW’s definition of social class in America and how it pertains to income, society and culture. The definition of social class according to Pew research and based on the results of their survey is the stratification of individuals based on income, education level, financial satisfaction, occupation wealth and prestige. Based on those factors individuals are grouped into levels of socioeconomic class namely: upper class, upper-middle class, lower-middle class, and lower class. For the sake of their survey, Pew research grouped together the individuals in the lower-middle class and lower class into one group. Any observer of American society would quickly note that there are large variations in wealth, material possessions, power and authority, and prestige in our society.  They would also note differences in access to education, healthcare and leisure. Income is one of the biggest measures or indicator of socioeconomic status. In the United States there is inequality in the distribution of income. Those in the upper class aka the elite represent the smallest percentage of the population yet they hold majority of the income. The opposite can be said for their friends at the end of the spectrum, they make us the largest part of the population and have the least amount of the income. According to Leonard Beeghley a household income of roughly $95,000 would be typical...

Words: 2191 - Pages: 9

Functionalist Explanations of Social Inequality

...Outline and Asses Functionalist explanations of social inequality (40marks) Functionalism is a concencus theory that focused on the unity and harmony of society. Functionalists believe that society is a system that works together in order for it to funtction. Inequality is the existence of unequal opportunities and rewards for different social positions in a society and recurrent patterns of unequal distributions of goods, wealth, opportunities etc. There are many types of inequality such as social class inequality, gender inequality, age inequality and ethnicity inequality. Functionalists believe that these inequalities do exist and that they are beneficial to the society and are vital for society to function. Parsons states that we need order, stability and cooperation based on a value consensus. He believes that the relationship between the different groups is one of reciprocity. This means that the different groups are good because they share a give and take relationship and are useful to each other. Parsons also talks about stratification systems (which is the existence of different layers in society)as inevitable and functional, we need this hierarchy in order to survive. Davis and Moore also look at the stratifications system and argue that it occurs in every known society and that in order for the stratification system to work we must have effective role allocation. Role allocation ensures that the roles in society are filled by those who are best suited to......

Words: 321 - Pages: 2

Outline and Assess Sociological Explanations of Social Class Stratification (40 Marks)

...Outline and assess sociological explanations of social class stratification (40) Social stratification is any given society's categorization of its people into rankings of socioeconomic tiers based on factors like wealth, income, social status, occupation, and power. Stratification is the relative social position of a person in a given social group. Functionalists such as Durkheim believe that class stratification exists because it is functional and beneficial towards social order and noted that societies are often characterized by a specialized occupational division of labour. According to Durkheim, members within a society are happy and comfortable within their position within the division of labour because there is a common agreement about how society should be organized which is referred to as value consensus. This also means that people accept social stratification as they see that different occupations should be graded in terms of their value to society and therefore those who have jobs which provide the most reward to society should in turn receive the most reward within a society. Durkheim also saw stratification as a benefit to society because it sets a limit to people’s aspirations and therefore people do not become overly ambitious and therefore disappointed when they are unable to reach specific goals. Instead, as the stratification system is regarded as equal and fair, people are contented with their position is society. However, Durkheim noted that there......

Words: 780 - Pages: 4

Sociological Explanations of Social Class Inequality

...There is much debate in sociology about whether class is still important. Many argue that class is no longer important as an individual’s identity and life chances are based more status and cultural factors such as lifestyle, values, intelligence, education and the like, the post-modernists state that class has ceased to be the prime determinant of identity and suggest that societies are now organised around consumption rather than production, consequently people now identify themselves in terms of what they consume rather than in terms of social-class position. Class identity has therefore fragmented into numerous separate and individualised identities. Others argue that class is still a central influence on people’s lives, that it affects their life chances (health, education, voting, social mobility etc.), they argue that class inequality exists and that such inequalities are widening rather than narrowing. Early theories such as Functionalist theory argue that inequality is functional for society since it makes sure that those who show the most potential talent are encouraged to develop this talent through higher education and training, with the promise of higher incomes when they qualify (deferred gratification). They state that in order for society to function properly, society must make sure that people fully use their talents. Inequalities stem from the fact that society values different roles in different ways, based on the shared norms and values of a society.......

Words: 1561 - Pages: 7


...Outline and asses the Weberian explanations of the changing structure in the contemporary UK In the last century the class structure in the UK has dramatically altered. In 1911 80% of employment was within a manual sector, meaning that under the registrar-generals model of social stratification they would have been described as working class. By 1995 according to Savage 67.3% of the population would be considered to be middle class. This was due to the closure of the heavy industries throughout the 1980’s and the increase in service occupations. The structure of the upper class has changed dramatically, as the ‘nouveau riche’ experience intragenerational movement the old upper class face loosing their birthrights due to issues such as inheritance tax. Furthermore women now form a bigger proportion of the workforce because of the emancipation of women which was caused by feminist movements and the feminisation of the workplace due to the reduction of manual work. Weber furthered on originally Marxist ideas, claiming that an individual’s class arises from the person’s market situation, meaning there is a division between those who have considerable property meaning they can live off the proceeds and the propertyless that have to sell their labour. However Weber furthered this, as of course, within the propertyless there are those who are able to sell their labour for a higher price, and unlike Marx, Weber saw that more than just different occupational groupings could form......

Words: 793 - Pages: 4

Social Class

...Examine the effects and significance of class on the following; -health -education -employment -personality development Give examples to support your discussions HEALTH Social support is one of most important factors in predicting the physical health and well-being of everyone, ranging from childhood through older adults. The absence of social support shows some disadvantage among the impacted individuals. In most cases, it can predict the deterioration of physical and mental health among the victims. The initial social support given is also a determining factor in successfully overcoming life stress. The presence of social support significantly predicts the individual's ability to cope with stress. Knowing that they are valued by others is an important psychological factor in helping them to forget the negative aspects of their lives, and thinking more positively about their environment. Social support not only helps improve a person's well-being, it affects the immune system as well. Thus, it also a major factor in preventing negative symptoms such as depression and anxiety from developing. The social support and physical health are two very important factors that help the overall well-being of the individual. A general theory that has been drawn from many researchers over the past few decades postulation that social support essentially predicts the outcome of physical and mental health for everyone. There are six criteria of social support that researchers use......

Words: 1921 - Pages: 8

The Social Class

...The social class now a day will have influence in their vote, but what is most influential is Income, and Aspiration. For instance a rich, upper class person will always vote for the Government that will tax them least, they do have a good income and everything they need, and they care lees for people who have much less. The upper middle class are the one who also objects to taxation, they often pay a lot of tax and resent it being 'wasted' on useless spending. However, many of these same people rely on the Government for their highly paid jobs, so there is a dichotomy here. They will classify spending money on the Health Service, and qualify 'waste' as money spent on anything they themselves don't approve of. Immigration (with no distinction of what kind of immigration they are talking about) is often touted as the basis of all the country's ills, the erroneous assumption being that the Government pays for all illegal immigrants and asylum seekers to live in hotels. They know that it would cost them more of their income to pay for Health Services privately than they pay in tax, but they still aspire to improve their lot. All political parties try to convince the public they have the perfect balance between prudent public spending and reasonable levels of taxation. Will vote for the party that sounds best on the day. The working class, that mass of group that keep the wheels of the nation running, the factory workers, the builders, the bakers, the plumbers,......

Words: 608 - Pages: 3