Defense Mechanisms and the Movie Shutter Island

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By lulito93
Words 363
Pages 2
What types of defense mechanisms do we use on a regular basis to avoid reality?

How positive are they?

Andrew Laeddis is the main character in the movie Shutter Island. He suffers from

schizophrenia and many other mental problems. The trigger happened after one day

he came back home from work and discovered that his wife had killed his three

children. She was mentally ill and felt no remorse for what she just did so Andrew

killed her.

As a result of such traumatic experience, he unconsciously invented another self,

created another story in which someone else had committed his wife’s and his own

crime. He even denied having any children.

At the end he drives himself crazy, and ends up in a mental institution.

It’s also important to mention that he went to war and he had lived traumatic

experiences prior to his family’s murder.

This is a great example for what is called “’defense mechanisms” and how they affect

our lives.

Everyday people are faced with problems, traumas, difficulties and emotional (and

even physical) pain. The mind, in order to protect itself from pain, usually creates

these defense mechanisms such as denial, habit, behavioral changes, isolation of

affect, etc.

Even though defense mechanisms can be positive for protecting the individual

against trauma, they can be extremely destructive in using them without awareness

and control.

Austrian neurologist Sigmund Freud researched defense mechanisms and post

traumatic stress disorder, stating that our unconscious often helps us cope with

unbearable feelings with different behaviours that we may or may not be aware of.

Andrew Laeddis went through severe trauma that caused him nightmares or

“visions”, that would make him relive it and creating severe conflict in his life

since he had been suppressing his memories…...

Similar Documents

Symbolism in Shutter Island

...Sam Collins Film Essay: 2012 question: Analyse how symbols are used to present an idea or ideas in a film Shutter Island by legendary American director Martin Scorsese is an elaborate labyrinth of a film. It's ever changing plot line and deeply emotional scenes make it compulsory viewing for any avid film goer. Scorsese has constructed this intricately woven film by using various film techniques the most significant of which is symbols. In the film symbols are used to present many different ideas to the audience. Scorsese who is a modern film icon constantly uses symbolism throughout his films to convey subtle ideas to the audience without them knowing. Three different motifs or symbols are used in the film to achieve this result. Water is firstly used to present the idea reality or truth; while fire is used to represent the idea of Teddy's' fantasy. ward "C" is used the film is used to represent the idea of Teddy's mental instability to the audience. These symbols are used throughout the film but primarily in three, firstly water in the opening scene. Fire is used in the scene where Teddy supposedly finds Solando and Ward C in the scene where Teddy is exploring the anoles to find Laeddis' cell. These symbols in combination create a very profound cinematic involvement for the audience and makes Shutter Island, a modern classic. The story begins on a steamboat heading towards the ominously secluded Ashecliffe mental hospital off the Boston, Massachusetts shore in......

Words: 2181 - Pages: 9

Shutter Island

...Running head: Shutter Island 1 Issues in Shutter Island Andrew Casey Introduction to therapeutic skills Fort Hays State University 2 The movie Shutter Island deals with a time period in the 1950s where a character by the name of Edward “teddy” Daniels, in his thirties, deals with some extreme situations. The movie starts off with Daniels on a boat heading towards Ashville hospital of the criminally insane on Shutter Island near the Boston Harbor. He is accompanied by his partner by the name of Chuck Aule throughout most of the movie. They end up getting stuck on the island and try to find a missing patient by the name of Rachel Solando. Daniel is denied many times in getting classified documents and even entering a part of the hospital. Daniels starts to get headaches and when he sleeps he has visions of Rachel Solando drowning her three kids. Towards the end he feels like the doctors are doing questionable experiments and treatments on patients. He also feels like they are giving him something that is causing him to get the headaches and that everyone is playing games with him. At the end of the movie he realizes that he’s not actually Edward Daniels but he is actually Andrew Laeddis. The doctor finally tells him He is the one that actually killed his wife and drowned his three kids and he can now remember what he had done and that he is actually a patient at the hospital. There seems to be a couple disorders that......

Words: 970 - Pages: 4

Defense Mechanisms

...Primitive Defense Mechanisms 1. Denial * Someone told you that your loved one died but, you refused to believe it, you still keep her clothes clean and wait for her to come home. * A friend told you that she saw your boyfriend with another girl in the cinema, and you refuse to believe it, you make yourself believe that maybe it was just his friend, sister, or cousin. * You’re friends told you to join a singing contest but, you refused, because you think you will never succeed, and there are better singers than you that will also join. 2. Acting Out * Your girlfriend broke up with you and you got mad that you punched the mirror and somehow it made you feel better. * Someone says or does something that makes you feel offended in some way. You lash out at them with loud verbal taunts or you attack them physically * You ask your parents or guardians to do something. They say no. You do that “fake crying” that often results in your parents giving in to your request. 3. Projection * You have a strong dislike for someone; you might instead believe that he or she does not like you. * Your group presentation failed because you didn’t bring some materials that are needed but, you blamed another person. * John was caught by her wife having an affair but, he blames his wife because she doesn’t have time for him anyway. Less Primitive Defense Mechanism 1. Repression * A child who is abused by a parent later has no recollection of the events...

Words: 683 - Pages: 3

Defense Mechanisms

...children to escape from the reality of being a murderer and being responsible for the death of his family. At the end, Andrew became mentally ill himself for refusing to accept reality. This is the story of the Movie “Shutter Island” which is an example for what is called “Defense Mechanisms” and how they have a huge effect on our lives. Due to the fact that everyday people are faced with problems, stress, conflict and emotional pain, the mind needs to be protected against these painful feelings. As a result, “Defense Mechanisms” play an important role during these times in order to protect the mind from Stress and Anxiety by “unconsciously” denying reality and refusing it. Although Defense Mechanisms have positive side that they protect the individual against painful thoughts and experiences but using them without awareness can be destructive. “Defense Mechanisms” were researched by Sigmund Freud who’s an Austrian neurologist who became well known as “Father of Psychoanalysis”. Freud defined “Defense Mechanisms” as people’s unconscious behavior to cope with distress and anxiety; in other words they are ways that people use “unconsciously” to escape from painful experiences which they do not want to deal with or think about. Freud identified some types of “Defense Mechanisms” that can be used by a person while trying to defend himself against anxiety. These types include: 1. Denial It is the refusal to accept reality, in which the person convinces himself that the problem......

Words: 2819 - Pages: 12

Defense Mechanisms

...wholly negative thing. It has let me move past the incident instead of dwelling on it and preventing me from having a caring relationship with my family. On the other hand, involvement in the church was and continues to be an important part of my family’s life and I’ve missed a lot of that. Denial is defined as, “arguing against an anxiety provoking stimuli by stating it doesn't exist,” according to www.allpsych.com. A common example is when a person receives a doctor’s diagnosis that they have cancer. Instead of accepting the news, they pass off the statements as untrue. This protects the person, because they are choosing not to acknowledge their diagnosis, while eliminating all feelings of sadness and hurt. I’ve noticed this defense mechanism at work in the actions of my mother. She has difficulty maintaining a budget. She spends well beyond her means but refuses to acknowledge the fact. Just recently she purchased a convertible sports car. What you have to know is that her only income is social security and a very small pension from my deceased father’s career. When we asked if she could afford the car and insurance she said there was plenty in her budget to cover the expense. This would have been true is she had no other financial commitments. Things like food, utilities and medical expenses. We have repeatedly tried to sit down with her and help lay out a budget, but she always finds a way to avoid or change the topic and pretend that everything is ok. Her home is......

Words: 1326 - Pages: 6

Shutter Island

...The movie Shutter Island is directed by Martin Scorsese and starring Leonard Dicaprio was released February 2010. The movie is based off the book of the same name. The book was written by Dennis Lehane. The book was written in 2003. The movie is set in Boston in the 1954. It started out with two U.S Marshall, Teddy and Chuck looking into the disappearing of a woman on a secretive mental institution for the criminally insane. Aschecliffe Hospital is a highly security federal asylum for the criminal insane. The only way on and off the island is the ferry. Upon reaching the Island, Teddy and his partner Chuck is brief on the patient that disappears from the island. The patient name is Rachel. Rachel was sent to the asylum because she drowned her three children and is in the stage of denial. She believed that she is still at home in Massachusetts Villages and that the other patients and staffs are her neighbors. While investigating the disappearing of Rachel, Teddy started having constant hallucinations, dreams and delusions about his wife. In one of his dream his wife appears to him and told him that the man who started the fire that killed her, Andrew Laeddis was stilled on the Island along with Rachel. While exploring and searching for the escaped patient, Teddy and Chuck had to seek shelter from the hurricane that reeking hell on the Island. While waiting out the storm in a building Teddy told Chuck about his traumatic experiences that he had while he was a solider in the......

Words: 604 - Pages: 3

Mature Defense Mechanisms

...Mature defense mechanisms are defined by a healthy and conscious relationship with reality. Uncomfortable feelings and thoughts are deliberately transformed into less threatening forms rather than being pushed aside. People decide and choose to cope using mature defense mechanisms; they don't just occur spontaneously. One form of a mature defense mechanism is suppression, which is a conscious form of repression. You choose to not engage or talk about upset feelings or thoughts. You are aware of them and not intimidated by them overly, but just decide to put off dealing with them for a while. You acknowledge the impulses, and we accept their presence and the fact that they might emerge again, to be reconciled or suppressed then. For example: "I'm mad at my mom, but it won't help to tell her that at this family party. I'll save this revelation for a time when we can speak about it privately". Another form is sublimation; Uncomfortable feelings and thoughts are transformed when a person chooses to take the energy behind these feelings and thoughts and put it towards a different, constructive purpose. For example: "I'm mad at my father, but instead of yelling at him (which won't help things), I’m going to do homework." Sublimation can also be done with humor or fantasy. Humor, when used as a defense mechanism, is the channeling of unacceptable impulses or thoughts into a light-hearted story or joke. Humor reduces the intensity of a situation, and places a cushion of laughter......

Words: 556 - Pages: 3

Shutter Island

...Harbour Islands, 1954 fog; a ferry appears; a man (Chuck) stands at the bow // INT. HEAD - DAY: a man being sick "It's just water. It's a lot of water." SHALLOW FOCUS on manacles and handcuffs, PULL FOCUS as he emerges He joins a solicitous Chuck at the rail. They introduce themselves – he is Teddy Daniels, a "legend" in the US Marshalls. Teddy concedes that he used to be married Day 1 EST. the wider context; from here on, everything will be from Teddy's POV. Our first view of the protagonist is a double and ambiguous image: his black silhouette and his reflection in a mirror, water dripping off his face. Water will be a significant motif. Teddy's first view of Chuck is a back view, through a link-chain fence (M). Chuck's full name is Chuck Aule (get it?). Clue: it is extremely unlikely that two US Marshalls sent to do a job together would meet like this on board the ferry. They would have been briefed together before boarding. F/B-PW (memory): INPOINT: the tie he is wearing a bare-footed Dolores puts it on him CU a radiant Dolores // the sea // Dolores' lovely face shift from the cold blues to warm golden-pinks M: the tie will be significant later; both Rachels will have bare feet. music on record player "She died. … There was a fire in our apartment building, while I was at work. … Four people died. It was the smoke that got her, not the fire. That's important." Chuck gives Teddy a cigarette, lights it. Teddy briefs Chuck:......

Words: 8295 - Pages: 34

Shutter Island

...Robert Kimble GMMD211 Shutter Island Scene Analysis The “Opening Scene” The 2010 movie Shutter Island is a psychological thriller that focuses on our main character “Teddy”. Portrayed by Leonardo DiCaprio, our protagonist believes he is a U.S. Marshal who is headed to a remote island, which houses an asylum for the criminally insane, to investigate the disappearance of one of their patients. The harsh reality is that “Teddy” is one of those patients, and the opening scene sets the tone for what is to follow. The opening scene starts with a greyish screen and only the diegetic sound of the waves, symbolizing perhaps being lost at sea with nothing but water surrounding you. We then hear the horn of a ship, followed by a long shot of the ship taking shape as it emerges from the fog. At the front of the ship we see a person standing alone facing the direction the ship is heading. This symbolizes that whomever it is, they are gaining clarity of what is to come. Cut to a medium shot, showing the interior of the boat where we see someone leaning over a toilet and hear them throwing up, meanwhile we also hear the rustling of the chains shown hanging in the forefront. Cut to an extreme close up of our main character looking into the mirror and saying to himself “pull yourself together Teddy, pull yourself together.” This scene wreaks of split personality disorder. This could have a parallel meaning that while “Teddy” is fighting with himself to regain control, it is......

Words: 870 - Pages: 4

Five Defense Mechanisms Examples

...Events related to Defense Mechanism Denial: when my grandfather passed away, I was told about it while I was still in university and after hearing it I went back to the lounge and laughed with my friends as if nothing happened. Projection: I’ve been wanting to eat healthy and stop eating junk food but I still do eat junk food and every time I see my brother having junk food I lecture him about how unhealthy and bad it, same thing happens when he asks for it. Repression: once my parents were having a fight and I just put my head phones on and started watching a movie as if nothing was happening and to this day I remember doing it but not to the extent that my sister remembers it. She says that my parents almost had a divorce but I remember it as a normal fight. Regression: when my younger brother was born. I started wanting to drink from the bottle again and sleep next to my parents. Reaction Formation: In school a lot of my classmates were super religious and had a strong opinion on praying like a person should force themselves to pray so they can be good Muslims but I don’t agree with that, I do miss prayers because I feel like a person should want to pray and it’s more than just getting the “job” done but I never said anything and would agree with them. Displacement: once before a wedding I didn’t like the way I did my hair and when my sister came to help me with my makeup I started screaming at her and telling her she’s doing things wrongly and it was because of......

Words: 294 - Pages: 2

Shutter Island

...effects. In Dennis Lehane’s Shutter Island there are many effects of a mental illness that are damaging to an individual. However, there are three effects that seem more harmful and long-term. First, many people who are sleep deprived tend to develop difficulties with their mental state. Furthermore a mental illness can often cause an individual to respond to an emotional situation in a violent fashion. Most importantly, when one’s mental state is damaged has a hard time remembering things flashbacks and distorted memories are common. Many people who suffer from psychological problems are often troubled with insomnia as a side effect because sleep requires an untroubled mind. Former United States Marshal, Teddy Daniels, believes he was assigned to find a missing person from a mysterious mental institution, Ashecliffe. Unfortunately, he suffers from a delusional disorder and is really a patient of the institution, known as Andrew Laeddis. He is considered a violent but intelligent patient who re-enacts a fake life that he has created for himself in Throughout Shutter Island, there are many psychological events presented to Teddy Daniels. As a detective Teddy is oblivious to the significance of each event and fails to realize everything pertains to him. At the beginning Teddy was one of the most criminally insane patients, really put a twist on the movie that was unforgettable. Although Roger Ebert propelled arguing questions about Shutter Island, I conclude that the film......

Words: 296 - Pages: 2

Shutter Island

...SHUTTER ISLAND It's 1954, and up-and-coming U.S. marshal Teddy Daniels is assigned to investigate the disappearance of a patient from Boston's Shutter Island Ashecliffe Hospital. He's been pushing for an assignment on the island for personal reasons, but before long he wonders whether he hasn't been brought there as part of a twisted plot by hospital doctors whose radical treatments range from unethical to illegal to downright sinister. Teddy's shrewd investigating skills soon provide a promising lead, but the hospital refuses him access to records he suspects would break the case wide open. As a hurricane cuts off communication with the mainland, more dangerous criminals "escape" in the confusion, and the puzzling, improbable clues multiply, Teddy begins to doubt everything - his memory, his partner, even his own sanity. In the end of the movie it is revealed that "Teddy" is actually a delusional mental patient in the hospital. He murdered his manic depressive wife Dolores Chanal after she drowned their three children. He was a mental patient at the hospital for two years, and the doctors decided to try a roleplay experiment to allow him to live out his delusional fantasy in order to come to grips with reality. The treatment plan works - and the patient is retold what has happened to him and he accepts what he did to his wife. However, in the final scene he relapses to a delusional state, and the administrator decides to lobotomize him. It is implied that he is faking......

Words: 283 - Pages: 2

Shutter Island

...Running Head: SHUTTER ISLAND 1 Shutter Island and Delusional Disorder Lynn Fontenot Ilze Nix University of Maryland University College 02/26/2012 SHUTTER ISLAND 2 Abstract A behind the scenes look at the disorder that plagues the character in “Shutter Island”. To inform the audience exactly what a Delusional Disorder is and what characterizes Delusional Disorder. SHUTTER ISLAND 3 “Shutter Island” is one of those films that glue you to the screen with suspense and mystery. Initially, we think we are watching a well-intentioned U.S. Marshall named Teddy enter an insane asylum hoping to uncover the whereabouts of a recently-disappeared patient. Later, we begin to doubt our initial idea of a simple missing person case. Now we think we are witnessing a brave, intelligent and dedicated U.S. Marshall searching for damning evidence that will......

Words: 1145 - Pages: 5

Shutter Island

...SHUTTER ISLAND It's 1954, and up-and-coming U.S. marshal Teddy Daniels is assigned to investigate the disappearance of a patient from Boston's Shutter Island Ashecliffe Hospital. He's been pushing for an assignment on the island for personal reasons, but before long he wonders whether he hasn't been brought there as part of a twisted plot by hospital doctors whose radical treatments range from unethical to illegal to downright sinister. Teddy's shrewd investigating skills soon provide a promising lead, but the hospital refuses him access to records he suspects would break the case wide open. As a hurricane cuts off communication with the mainland, more dangerous criminals "escape" in the confusion, and the puzzling, improbable clues multiply, Teddy begins to doubt everything - his memory, his partner, even his own sanity. In the end of the movie it is revealed that "Teddy" is actually a delusional mental patient in the hospital. He murdered his manic depressive wife Dolores Chanal after she drowned their three children. He was a mental patient at the hospital for two years, and the doctors decided to try a roleplay experiment to allow him to live out his delusional fantasy in order to come to grips with reality. The treatment plan works - and the patient is retold what has happened to him and he accepts what he did to his wife. However, in the final scene he relapses to a delusional state, and the administrator decides to lobotomize him. It is implied that he is faking......

Words: 278 - Pages: 2

Symbolism in Shutter Island

...Sam Collins Film Essay: 2012 question: Analyse how symbols are used to present an idea or ideas in a film Shutter Island by legendary American director Martin Scorsese is an elaborate labyrinth of a film. It's ever changing plot line and deeply emotional scenes make it compulsory viewing for any avid film goer. Scorsese has constructed this intricately woven film by using various film techniques the most significant of which is symbols. In the film symbols are used to present many different ideas to the audience. Scorsese who is a modern film icon constantly uses symbolism throughout his films to convey subtle ideas to the audience without them knowing. Three different motifs or symbols are used in the film to achieve this result. Water is firstly used to present the idea reality or truth; while fire is used to represent the idea of Teddy's' fantasy. ward "C" is used the film is used to represent the idea of Teddy's mental instability to the audience. These symbols are used throughout the film but primarily in three, firstly water in the opening scene. Fire is used in the scene where Teddy supposedly finds Solando and Ward C in the scene where Teddy is exploring the anoles to find Laeddis' cell. These symbols in combination create a very profound cinematic involvement for the audience and makes Shutter Island, a modern classic. The story begins on a steamboat heading towards the ominously secluded Ashecliffe mental hospital off the Boston, Massachusetts shore in......

Words: 2181 - Pages: 9