Case Note

In: Social Issues

Submitted By mardy
Words 743
Pages 3
Case Note: Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co

Introduction
This case note comments on the decision of Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256. It examines whether any person who act upon the required conditions of a contract is legally bounded by this unilateral offer.

The significance of the case lies in the establishment of a precedent that an offer of contract can be unilateral and does not have to be made to a specific party. It also established that notification is not necessarily required in the acceptance of offers, and that once an individual meets the required conditions, the contract is activated.

Facts
The plaintiff is Mrs. Carlill and the defendant is Carbolic Smoke Ball Company, which is a company that sold carbolic smokeball, an influenza remedy. In a newspaper advertisement the defendant claimed that the people who contacted influenza after having used the smoke ball as directed in the advertisement would be rewarded £100. In order to show the sincerity of this offer, the defendants had deposited £1000 with the Alliance Bank. Believing so, the plaintiff bought and used the smokeball as directed, but soon after continuous usage of it she contracted influenza.

Issues
There are four main issues in this case, namely (1) whether the advertisement on the newspaper is an offer or a mere puff by the defendant, (2) and how can be distinguish an advertisement from a puff, (3) whether communication of acceptance is necessary in the formation of a contract, (4) whether an offer can be addressed to the whole world.

Rule
In determining whether a contract is concluded the courts look at two elements, namely offer and acceptance. In looking at the element of offer, if the defendant demonstrates an intention to be legally bound, then he is said to wish to enter into an agreement. This distinguishes an offer from a mere puff, of which indicates…...

Similar Documents

Additional Note on Progressive Case

...ADDITIONAL NOTE ON PROGRESSIVE CASE (TO BE CONSIDERED FOR CASE ANALYSIS) In March 2000 Progressive began to offer a new product: homeowners insurance. Made available first in an Arizona pilot, the program was extended to Michigan in October 2000, Maryland in January 2001, and Illinois in September 2001. Marketed initially through specially selected and trained independent insurance agents, Progressive’s homeowners policies were eventually to be\ offered, along with its primary product, auto insurance, through the company’s two direct channels, its 800-number and web site. Many consumers sought the convenience of bundling auto and homeowners insurance rather than dealing with separate companies for each policy. Some insurers even offered discounts to customers who consolidated their coverage. Progressive executives thus viewed homeowners insurance as a natural extension of the company’s auto-insurance product suite. In 1997 Progressive ran a trial partnership in Ohio with Travellers Casualty, a major player in homeowners insurance, whereby consumers were offered homeowners quotes when they called for auto insurance. By 2000, Progressive had decided to offer its own homeowners product. 2 The product was launched slowly in select states. The move into homeowners seemed an obvious choice for Progressive. The data-driven company had success in providing auto insurance rates that more accurately (and less expensively) reflected individual consumers’ coverage needs. Cross-selling......

Words: 1184 - Pages: 5

Guide to Individual Case Preparation Case Notes Template

...Guide to Individual Case Preparation Case Notes Template The following outline and question areas are intended as a guide to your thinking for case preparation. Some question areas, as noted, are required for each case, while others are relevant only for selected cases, depending on the content and focus of the case. You may use this template to guide your preparation of your individual notes on assigned cases. If your notes are handwritten, rather than typed, they must be submitted as photocopies as evidence you have prepared your notes before class. I. Current Situation A. Current Performance (required) How has the organization performed in recent years in terms of return on investment, market share, and profitability? (This section must be based on and present evidence of your conduct of appropriate numerical analyses of the firm’s market and financial performance i.e. ratio analyses and/or change (and percentage change) over time in key market and financial measures over time.) Your task is to conduct analyses and discover possible problems facing the company, not to just present data. What are the organization’s current mission, objectives, strategies and policies? B. Corporate Governance Who are the Board of Directors and what is their level of involvement in strategic management? C. Top Management What person or group constitutes top management? Have they established a systematic approach to strategic management? Are strategic decisions made...

Words: 1898 - Pages: 8

Case Notes Citi

...Citibank Case Analysis Citibank: Launching the credit card in Asia Pacific Country entry strategy Objectives of this case ... q To understand market evaluation, target market selection, and product positioning issues in services operations. q To appreciate globalization/country entry issues in financial products. q To understand the underlying economics of customer acquisition and retention. Key Strategic Issues qShould Citibank launch the card product ? Why ? Why not ? qGiven the upscale customer base , how should Citibank position its card, if it decides to launch it ? qWhich countries should Citibank enter first? Which countries should it avoid? Few More Operational Issues qHow should Rana Talwar convince his country managers and H.Q to accept the card product? What Organizational mechanisms does he have under his control? qIf you choose not to introduce the card, what do you do to achieve the $100 mio. earnings target by 1990? What kind of Branch banking products should the bank offer? Economic Analysis q How many card customers does Citibank need to break even on its investment ? Economic Analysis q First step is to ascertain the credit card revenue per customer of $163 (table B page 6) qOptions available: - assume Hong Kong experience as “typical” of the region. - If we have to target affluent with premium positioning you may use $250/ customer - for mass market strategy take $140/ customer Cost component of analysis qThree......

Words: 2441 - Pages: 10

Case Notes

...Case Notes Student Name University Case Notes Soap Case Note: Client Description: Client is a 52 year old, divorced African-American female with 2 children. Client has a 13 year old son and a daughter who is an adult. Client is dressed appropriate and is well groomed. 8/8/13 (S) Client reports have a lot of difficulty understanding her 13-year-old son. She stated her son “holds on to anger and can lash out at the drop of the hand”. She reports the last episode occurred when her son was outside, playing with some friends and one of the boys said something to him. She does not know what was said but her son just exploded. Client stated she is “concerns because she does not want anyone to hurt him and he gets angry over the least a little bit of thing that someone says to him”. As a result client reports arguing with her son and they both end up anger at one another. She is an older parent, and she reports have a little patience with her son. (O) Client is a little frustration in reference to her son angry issues. In the beginning of the counseling session the client appears frustrated when she discusses some examples of her disagreement with her son about his anger and temper issues. Towards the end of the session the client was smiling and able to identify a better way to talk to her son by using different approach without being so angry. (A) Client feels hurt and anger because she is unable to communicate with her son when he gets anger. Client reports......

Words: 1363 - Pages: 6

3m Post-It Notes Case Study

...Post it Notes – Case Study Questions Question 1 In the development of this product, how did the creative thinking process work? Describe what took place in each of the four steps. . The Post-It Notes case has clearly illustrated the 4 phases in creativity development and each step has demonstrated by the inventor of Post-It Notes as described below: * Background or knowledge accumulation This phase was demonstrated by Art Fry who is the inventor of Post-It Notes whereby he recalled about the adhesive invented by Dr. Spencer Silver from a seminar he attended in the past. He approaches the R&D department to gather a background information and knowledge about adhesives that developed by Dr. Spencer Silver. * The mind incubation process This incubation process occurs while Art Fry singing in the church choir. Most of the time, the bookmark kept failing out of his hymnal, causing him to lose his page while performing. This prompted him to find a solution or something that could adhere to the page but not tear it. He went on to explore the possibility with the helps from R&D team and managed to find a low-tack adhesive that turn out to be a perfect solution to prevent the bookmark falling out. * The idea experience As Fry’s idea of applying the low-tack adhesive on the bookmark was proven an effective solution, he begin to realize that the same concept could possible turn into a new product. * Evaluation and Implementation This phase was......

Words: 725 - Pages: 3

Tanishq Case Notes

...Concept Case Notes – Tanishq: Positioning to capture the Indian Woman’s Heart. ________________________________________________________________________________________________ OVERVI EW: * Indian Jewellery industry * Tanishq and Goldplus SWOT analysis * Problem Analysis * Success strategies * Market Segmentations * Findings & Understandings India's Jewellery Industry: * Indian gold jewellery market~Rs. 60,000 crores Annually * Indian wedding jewellery-~70% of jewellery market * Wedding trousseau consisting of at least 5 pieces~$2,550 where per capita income was~$350 Tanishq – SWOT Analysis: * Strenghts Capital Flexibility Innovative Modern Style Excellent & outstanding advertisement strategy * Weaknesses 'Not for me' Gold Purchase Rituals Gold Perceptive * Opportunities TATA Support The Wedding Market Globalization * Threats Goldplus Local Jewelers Gold Significance Government Regulations Goldplus SWOT Analysis: * Strenghts Marketing Strategy TATA Support Traditions & Values * Weaknesses Limited Outlets * Opportunities Outlets The Rural Market * Threats Tanishq Government Regulations Design Stealers Vision of Undisciplined Boy! Problem Analysis : * Heavy Competition * Failure of Gold watches * Failure to tap wedding Market * "Not for Me "perception * Internal conflicts between Tanishq and Goldplus Succesful......

Words: 309 - Pages: 2

Warnings Case Study with Notes

...Case study: Warbings Office Systems Plc Background Warbings Office Systems is small but rapidly growing company, focusing on delivering and supplying office based products to a target market of small businesses in the U.K. and, increasingly, Europe. As the trend for homeworking continues much of their new business is in supplying office materials to individuals working from home. Currently offering some 18,000 different product lines in store and 39,000 via catalogue ordering, it intends to double its product turnover in the next three years by increasing its web-based ordering capabilities. With the marketing strapline ‘you need it we’ve got it’, Warbings aims to make office supply shopping as easy as possible for customers. Priding itself on being a ‘thoroughly modern company with old traditions,’ Warbings has used technology to evolve into a customer-focused business, striving to give each customer a ‘personal service second to none,’ with a variety of different, but easily accessible, ways of ordering and receiving products tailored to their individual needs. The more cynical of their staff occasionally reflect that the customers even dictate the lavatory breaks and bedtimes of the Warbings’ employees. Graffiti on one of the depot walls, that intriguingly reappears every time it is removed, says ‘you need it we bleed it’ and occasionally ‘Wosp stings’. The Warbings CEO is passionate about delivery and customer care and he is convinced that the way in......

Words: 2640 - Pages: 11

Rba Note Case Study

...RBA Note Printing Case Back ground- NPA prints banknotes for the RBA, Australian passports, and banknotes for a small number of other countries, while Securency manufactures, markets and supplies a range of polymer substrates on which banknotes are printed by NPA and others. In July 2011, the AFP announced that it had charged two subsidiaries of the RBA, NPA and Securency, as well as six former banknote executives, with paying bribes to foreign officials 'in order to win banknote supply contracts. In August 2011, the AFP reported that a seventh individual had been charged. At the time, the RBA wholly owned NPA and owned 50 per cent of Securency. Facts related to various scandals and governance failings- The AFP investigation relates to alleged bribes paid to public officials in up to six countries including Indonesia, Malaysia and Vietnam between 1999 and 2005. The allegations are that senior managers from Securency and NPA used international sales agents to bribe foreign public officials to secure bank note contracts. The charges against the individuals relate to subsections and of the Criminal Code Act 1995 which carry a maximum penalty of 10 years’ imprisonment and/or a $1.1 million fine. The case is the first of its kind under Australia's foreign bribery legislation which came into effect in December 1999. AFP investigations were pursued concurrently with related investigations by overseas law enforcement agencies involving cooperation with the UK's Serious Fraud...

Words: 1118 - Pages: 5

Case Notes - Dinsney

... Governing the House of the Mouse: Corporate Governance at Disney from 1984-2006 CASE ASSIGNMENT At the departure of Eisner, Chairman George Mitchell and new CEO Robert Iger are preparing to move the company forward. They have invited your consulting firm to meet with the new Board of Directors and discuss the situation at Disney. To familiarize yourself with the client, your first task is to prepare a background report which analyzes Disney's business environment and strategy. 1. What external forces and industry conditions have had an impact on Disney's performance over the years? 2. How did the internal organization and culture at Disney influence its performance? 3. How has Disney strategically responded to its competitive environment and internal capabilities? You have been asked to present a five-minute overview of the root causes of Disney's governance issues. The content of this brief presentation should achieve the following goals. 4. Identify the causes and consequences of the Board of Directors' ineffectiveness. 5. Highlight other governance weaknesses that have made Disney vulnerable to managerial opportunism. To be prepared for the ensuing discussion, you'll also need to be familiar with the following items. 6. How have governance mechanisms at Disney been used in the past, and what was their effect? 7. What unprecedented maneuvers were made by Disney stakeholders to overcome internal governance weaknesses? During the discussion, you should be able to......

Words: 5634 - Pages: 23

Human Resources Case Notes

...Sample Case 1 Ethics and Social Responsibility Case A New Concern for Human Resource Managers: Whistle-Blowing Each year Time dedicates a front cover of its magazine to a “Person of the Year.” Last year, for example, New York City Mayor Rudolph Giuilani was given such an honor for his handling of New York’s 9/11 terrorist crisis. This year Time expanded its version of the person of the year. It dedicated its cover to “Persons of the Year.” The magazine identified three women working in unrelated fields who had at least one common characteristic—they were all “Whistle-Blowers.” The term whistle-blower is defined by the third edition of The American Heritage College Dictionary as “One who brings wrong doing within an organization to light.” The etymology of the term whistle-blower is quite interesting and can be attributed to several sources: the police used whistles in early times as a communication signal and trains used their whistles to communicate warning signals. Today, the term whistleblower has a mixed meaning: it can have a negative connation in certain sectors with whistle-blowers being called, among other words, “traitor,” “turncoat,” and “rat.” Or, it can have a positive connation with whistle-blowers being called heroes. The three women profiled as Time’s Persons of the Year fall into that latter category. They “did the right thing” by informing their respective bosses of wrongdoings such as mismanagement, law breaking, and fraud. In essence, these brave women......

Words: 2842 - Pages: 12

Case Notes

...Case Notes: What to Write; How to Write; and What to Avoid? (Presentation by Bruce Benson, M.S.Ed. @ Seta Conference) Why are case records important? Assessment summary a. Capture relevant data elements”! b. Present accurate customer “snap shot”! c. Deficiencies and barriers should link directly to services and activities! Case management Guide a. Sequential tracking and reporting of customer contact and progress! b. Capture newly emerging barriers! c. Revise action plan! Accountability a. WIA axiom = “If it ain’t in writing, it never happened!” b. Internal oversight! c. Monitoring and auditing! Professional and ethical responsibility a. Human services and helping professions identify record keeping as an important ethical requirement! Information Sharing a. “In-house” sharing of important data and action plans critical to successful customer service! b. “External” sharing is critical to optimizing referral relationships with outside partner agencies! 1 How to Write Case Notes Write Case Notes that are: • Clear and brief • Concise, precise • Accurate and complete • Timely • Readable – acceptable grammar What • • • • • Case • • • • • you should avoid: Avoid “diagnoses” Avoid “Clichés” Avoid “street talk” Avoid Jargon Avoid Stereotypes and prejudices Notes should: Describe behaviors reported by customer and collateral contact! Record statements made by customer! Record your observations! Substantiate conclusions and......

Words: 356 - Pages: 2

Case Notes

...THE SATERA TEAM CASE NOTES PROBLEM STATEMENT The main problem in this case is the growing disagreement between two senior members of the team which is affecting the overall team performance and the working environment. Both the members are very skilled but have very different working styles, and hence most of the time they find it difficult to get to a common ground. Following are some problems which the Satera team project is facing right now • Relationship conflict between two senior mechanical engineers of the team. • This conflict is destroying team cohesion • Lack of communication among team members • Team as a whole is failing to meet the deadline. OB THEORIES Diversity, cohesion and productivity: The Satera team consists of people who are very skilled and have a different approach towards every situation. The issue in this team is the lack of cohesion among the team members. The two senior mechanical engineers of the team - Ira Lovas and David Bennett, have a very different style of working and hence rarely agree with each other. This lack of harmony among these two members is increasing and creating an unfavorable working environment for other team members. The productivity of the whole team is adversely affected and the team is failing to meet the deadlines. Both the senior engineers are equally required in this team for this project and hence it is important to keep them both in the team. Mr. Pinto who is leading the team seems to have an equal amount of......

Words: 542 - Pages: 3

Dupont Case Notes

... | |7.40 | Note that we predict proceeds per share will decrease over time due to the increased flotation and under-writing costs resulting from large equity issues. Also, we expect market price to slightly decrease due to the increased supply of company stock, or the dilution of shareholder value. [pic] The table illustrates that the WACC at 40% debt increases exponentially over the five-year priod. This could be explained by the increased risk associated with the increasing debt to total capitalization ratio. At 40%, DuPont has less financial flexibility as the available funds at reasonable costs decrease with an increase in leverage. The WACC at 25% debt is relatively consistent over time, assuming actual market prices are close to expected levels. This may be attributed to the more flexible nature of equity, whose costs depend on dividends declared and its annual growth, both of which reflect the discretion of top management and company policy. It is important to note that the weighted average cost of capital is merely an intelligent estimate. Actual levels may vary immensely due to the uncertainty involved in forecasting market trends and predicting changes in expectations which affect stock market prices.......

Words: 3396 - Pages: 14

Turner Case Notes

...3rd move in less than 2 years. A number of his MBA classmates were between positions and having a hard time finding a good place to land. o He really liked Chicago and had bought a condo at a good price, left him very little wiggle room financially • Tried to put his last 6 months into perspective o Had taken job with substantial autonomy, good chance for advancement, and what seemed like a very good relationship with company president o BUT relationship had soured, his autonomy had been severely curtailed, and his chances for advancement looked increasingly dim • He could no longer continue with things as they were and wanted to take some kind of immediate action to improve the situation • He reviewed his list of problems and his notes about how to address them: o Specifically, what was the most important issue and how should he frame it for Cardullo?...

Words: 3594 - Pages: 15

Case 37 Note

...Case #37 Baker Adhesives Synopsis and Objectives Baker Adhesives (Baker) has just made its first foray into international sales and must come to grips with the impact of exchange-rate changes on the profitability of a past order. The company must also formulate a strategy for dealing with exchange-rate risks for future orders. The case is intended as an introduction to exchange-rate risk and the management of that risk. Upon receipt of payment from a past order, the firm realizes that exchange-rate movements have reduced the value of the sale. A follow-on order provides the context for exploring possible mechanisms for managing that risk. In particular, sufficient direction and information is provided to examine both a forward hedge and a money-market hedge. The learning objectives of the case are as follows: • To explore the magnitude and effect of exchange-rate risks. • To illustrate exchange-rate risk management through two conventional hedges—a forward-contract hedge and a money-market hedge. • To demonstrate market parity and identify how preferences arise from unique company characteristics. • To explore issues related to pricing of international bids. Suggested Questions 1. How profitable is the original sale to Novo once the exchange-rate changes are acknowledged? How might the exchange-rate risk, which affected the value of the order, have been managed? 2. Assuming Baker agrees to the new Novo sale, determine the present value of the expected......

Words: 331 - Pages: 2